GENERAL
WAINWRIGHT BROADCASTING
surrender instructions over Station KZRH, 7 May 1942. |
|
For almost a half hour the six Americans
waited tensely on the open porch of the house, facing Manila Bay, a
short distance away. It was a windy day and from the beach rose a dense
cloud of sand and dust. The only Japanese who approached was an orderly
who brought cold water, which they accepted gratefully. Finally a group
of photographers arrived and the Americans were ordered to line up on
the lawn to have their pictures taken. They were still there at 1700
when General Homma drove up in a Cadillac, saluted with a vague flourish
of the hand, and strode up to the porch. Behind him were his principal
staff officers, correspondents, and more photographers. The Americans
followed silently.
The contrast between the two rival
commanders on the porch was striking. Unlike most Japanese, General
Homma was a large man, about five feet ten inches in height,
barrel-chested and heavy-set, weighing close to two hundred pounds. His
manner was assured and his bearing erect. His regulation olive drab
uniform, with white shirt open at the collar, was fresh and crisp.
Pinned to his chest were several rows of brightly colored decorations
and ribbons, and at his side hung a sword. General Wainwright, who had
earned the nickname "Skinny" long before he had undergone the privations
of Bataan and Corregidor, was over six feet tall, but weighed only about
160 pounds. He was "thin as a crane," observed one of the Japanese
correspondents, and "made a pathetic figure against the massive form of
General Homma." His uniform, the best he had, consisted of khaki shirt
and trousers; he wore no decorations and carried only a bamboo cane to
support a trick knee. In his eyes and in the deep lines etched in his
face could be read the story of the withdrawal from Lingayen Gulf, the
long, drawn-out siege of Bataan, and the terrific bombardment of
Corregidor.
The meeting opened as soon as everyone was
seated, without any exchange of courtesies. Wainwright made the first
move by reaching into his pocket for his formal signed surrender note
which he tendered to the Japanese commander. Although General Homma
could read and speak English, he did not look at the paper but turned it
over to his interpreter to be read aloud in Japanese for the benefit of
the other Japanese officers present. After it was read, Homma stated
through the interpreter that the surrender would not be accepted unless
it included all American and Philippine troops in the Islands. To this
Wainwright replied that he commanded only the harbor defense troops.
"Tell him," he said to the interpreter, "that the troops in the Visayan
Islands and on Mindanao are no longer under my command. They are
commanded by General Sharp, who in turn is under General MacArthur's
high command."
Homma refused to believe Wainwright's
explanation. Repeatedly, he pointed out, the American radio had named
Wainwright as commander of all troops in the Philippines. He had even
seen, he said, the general order announcing Wainwright's assumption of
command. Wainwright stubbornly insisted that the Visayan-Mindanao Force
was no longer under his control. Shrewdly, Homma asked when he had
released Sharp from his command. "Several days ago," Wainwright
answered, adding that even if he did command the troops in the south he
had no way of communicating with them. Homma brushed this argument aside
easily. "Send a staff officer to Sharp," he replied. "I will furnish a
plane."
The argument over command continued
several minutes more but Wainwright would not budge from his position,
asserting repeatedly that he did not have the authority to surrender the
Visayan-Mindanao Force. Finally Homma rose, looked down at Wainwright,
and said, "At the time of General King's surrender in Bataan I did not
see him. Neither have I any reason to see you if you are only the
commander of a unit ... I wish only to negotiate with my equal. . . ."
He seemed ready to leave.
Wainwright was in no position to bargain.
Uppermost in his mind was the thought that the troops on Corregidor were
disarmed and helpless. If Homma refused now to accept his surrender,
these men faced certain death. After a hurried conference with Beebe and
Pugh, he agreed to surrender the entire Philippine garrison.28
General Homma now refused to accept the surrender. "You have denied your
authority . . .," he told Wainwright, "I advise you to return to
Corregidor and think the matter over. If you see fit to surrender, then
surrender to the commanding officer of the division on Corregidor. He in
turn will bring you to me in Manila." With these words Homma left the
meeting.